| |
| |
This
article has been published by the
"Australian Strength & Conditioning Association" in their
magazine.
“Strength & Conditioning Coach” Volume
11 (3) 2003 |
| |
| By
Leith Darkin |
| May
2003 |
|
|
Part
1) Gravity and human evolution
Part 2) Gravity and resistance training
Part 3) Gravity, posture and transversus abdominus
Part 4) What is training?
PART 1
Gravity and human evolution
“Gravity” a very important contributing factor when it
comes to life on Earth. We all know gravity exists, we’ve all
heard the story of the apple that fell on Isaac Newtons head, but do
we really understand or appreciate how important gravity is, how it
influences everything we do and how our whole evolutionary process was
shaped by gravity.
One could say that gravity is the architect of human design, it specifically
designed our body so that we could co exist together. Our bones are
our bodies main support structure along with transversus abdoninus,
this enables us to stand upright, resisting the compressive force of
gravity. Our muscles connect to our bones to form a lever system, this
allows us to move around freely in the presence of gravity. Our heart
is designed to pump blood in an upward direction to the brain resisting
gravity, while the veins in our legs have one way valves which are designed
to open when our leg muscles contract then close to stop the blood flowing
downwards in the direction of gravity. The way in which we consume food
and pass waste products is solely reliant on gravity. The position of
a fetus in relation to the birth cannel and the actual birthing process
is reliant on gravity. The position of a woman’s breasts, the
way in which a baby suckles from its mother and the direction of milk
flow are all reliant on gravity.
Another way of examining how important gravity is to human evolution
is to examine what happens to humans when gravity is removed.
Studies on astronauts in space have revealed that gravity is more than
a force, it is also a signal that tells the body how to act. For one
thing, it tells muscles and bones how strong they must be. In zero gravity,
bones loose density at the rate of 1% a month. Muscles atrophy quickly,
because the body perceives it does not need them. Muscle mass can vanish
at a rate as high as 5% a week. When astronauts return from long-term
stints in space, they sometimes need to be carried away on stretchers
as the atrophy of their muscles and loss of strength makes it too hard
for them to stand upright in the presence of gravity. (Gravity hurts
by Karen Miller)
Other factors of zero gravity include increased blood pressure in the
brain, this results in a 22% reduction in blood volume in the first
2-3 days of zero gravity. With a reduction in blood volume the heart
doesn’t have to work as hard and results in atrophy of the heart.
(Dr. Victor Schneider, research medical officer for NASA).
|
| |
|
PART 2
Gravity and resistance training
What is the key ingredient
to resistance training? “Gravity” Without gravity you could
pick up a 100-lb. dumbell and throw it around like a tennis ball (astronauts
move satellites weighing several tun with one hand). If for some reason
gravity’s force was to increase then that 100-lb. dumbell would
weigh more.
The next important consideration when it comes to resistance training
is “alignment with gravity”. When standing in an upright position
our alignment is perfect for an overhead push (e.g. military press) and
an over head pull (e.g. Chin up) however our alignment with gravity is
incorrect for our horizontal push (bench press) and our horizontal pull
(bench pull). To correct our alignment for our bench press we need to
lie supine (horizontal, face up) and for our bench pull lie prone (horizontal,
face down). |
| |
| |
| |
| When
looking at compound exercises for the upper body you’ll find we have
our “Vertical Push & Pull”(1&5), our “Horizontal
Push & Pull”(3) and our 45degree variations (2&4). Our 45degree
variations amount to cross training between our vertical and horizontal
joint angles. In total this gives us five “Push” and five “Pull”
exercises. |
| |
| |
|
1) Chin up or lat pulldown
2) Incline lat pulldown
3) Bench pull
4) BB bent over row
5) Upright row |
1) Over head press
2) Incline bench press
3) Bench press
4) Decline bench press
5) Dips |
| |
When training the
upper body, your five “push” and five “Pull” exercises
are the nucleus of functional strength and all other compound exercises
for the upper body are variations of your five “Push” and “Pull”
exercises.
When training the lower body, your functional strength exercises are.
1) The “Squat” and its variations (The “Squat” replicates
standing upright to resist gravity with an external load, the path the bar
travels is in line with gravity).
2) The “Deadlift” and its variations (The “Deadlift”
replicates resisting gravity to stand upright while lifting an external
load from ground level, the path the bar travels is in line with gravity).
3) The “Lunge” and its variations (The “Lunge” replicates
resisting gravity while walking with an external load.)
Our five “Push & Pull” exercises, our “Squat”
and “Deadlift” are all performed in a stationary position, this
means it is easier to keep direct alignment with gravity. Our “Walking
Lunge”, “Step forward Lunge” or “Step Back Lunge”
are more dynamic in nature, our hip joint provides the horizontal movement,
our knee joint provides the vertical movement while our upper body stays
upright aligned with gravity. |
| |
|
What is the difference between compound and isolation and why
do we call compound movement “Functional” movement?
There are two types of motion the human body is capable of producing
from our lever system.
1) “Angular Motion” which is rotation around an axis. An axis
in the human body can be a joint between two bones, in which case the
movement around an axis is created by the pull from the muscles attached
to the bones either side of the joint (The term isolation means movement
at one joint).
2) “Linear motion” is motion in a straight line created by
compound (multi joint) movement. When looking at the joint mechanics to
produce motion in a straight line, you’ll find that the individual
joint movements are actually created by angular motion (rotation around
an axis), however when these individual joint movements are activated
in the right sequence, you have movement in a straight line
|
| |
| |
| |
| The above picture
is of an individual throwing a punch, the punch moves in a straight line
(linear motion) however it is created from rotation at the shoulder and
elbow joint. |
| |
| We tend
to call compound movement functional movement for the same reason that when
we talk about functional strength we prescribe compound exercises. With
compound or functional movement we have movement across several joints producing
movement in a straight line. Keeping movement in a straight line is what’s
required for keeping alignment with gravity (e.g. our five “Push”
& “Pull” exercises). With isolation exercises we have movement
at one joint which means we don’t keep alignment with gravity. |
| |
| |
The
above figure represents a DB Bicep Curl, you’ll notice that the
path the DB travels is different to the alignment with gravity. Ideally
an Upright Row would be a more functional movement to raise an external
load from hip to shoulder height, which would maintain alignment with
gravity and in turn alleviate the sheering force gravity has placed on
the elbow joint.
Compound exercises generally allows the human body to move an external
load in alignment with gravity which in turn alleviates allot of the sheering
force placed on the joints. Isolation exercises tend to increase the amount
of sheering force that gravity places on our joints. |
| |
PART
3
Gravity, posture and transversus abdominus
What is the main
contributing factor to poor posture? “Gravity”.
You’ll find that in women (especially women with larger breasts),
gravity will exaggerate their thoracic curve, protract their scapulae
and give them that rounded shoulder appearance. This happens because of
the additional weight of their breasts protruding forwards is pulled by
gravity in a downwards direction, this in turn pulls their shoulders forward,
which exaggerates their thoracic curve and changes their upper body alignment
with gravity.
In men it’s the extra weight that accumulates around the midriff
that generally leads to an exaggerated lumbar curve. Once again the additional
weight protruding forwards is pulled by gravity in a downward direction,
this in turn exaggerates the lumbar curve and changes their upper body
alignment with gravity.
|
| |
| |
| |
| With perfect
posture, the centerline of gravity runs in a downward direction through
C1, through the shoulder joint, through our hip joint, through our knee
joint and through our ankle joint. |
| |
Transversus
Abdominus
Over recent years there’s
been allot of discussion about Transversus Abdominus (TA) and the more
effective ways to strengthen TA, when looking at exercise prescription
for TA we need to first look at how TA works and what it is designed to
do.
TA is the main support system for our trunk, it holds and supports our
trunk when standing upright allowing us to resist gravity as a compressive
force, it works in conjunction with our diaphragm, pelvic floor and multifidus
(deep erector spinae muscle). TA wraps around our trunk, attaching either
side of our spinal column with the upper portion attaching to the ribs
and the lower portion attaching to the pelvis. The main function of TA
is to act like a corset when it is contracted. As TA contracts, it pushes
our intestines and internal organs in an upward direction against our
diaphragm and in a downward direction against our pelvic floor muscles
which in turn increases our inter abdominal pressure (our core area is
now acting like an air shock absorber). The amount of pressure we can
build up in our core area is relative to the strength of TA, the more
strength the more pressure and just like our car shock absorber, the more
air we pump into it, the greater the pressure, this means we can have
more weight in the back of the car or more weight in the trailer |
| |
Pilates,
Swiss balls & Freeweights
Although it has been proven
that Pilate floor exercises, Pilate machines and Swiss Balls are effective
tools for strengthening TA, especially in dysfunctional individuals, my
question is “are these forms of training the most effective way
to strengthen TA?” In my opinion “no”. As humans we
didn’t evolve over millions of years sitting and lying on Swiss
Balls and Pilate machines. Another fault with Swiss Ball exercises, Pilate
floor exercises and Pilate machine exercises used for strengthening TA,
is that the majority of exercises are done in the prone or supine position,
this means TA is stabilizing our trunk while resisting gravity as a sheering
force to our spine. When looking at our evolutionary process, our principle
of training “Specificity” would suggest that it would be more
preferable to strengthen TA to resist gravity as a compressive force.
Although another important principle of training “Variety”
would deem that a portion of training to strengthen TA should or could
be done in the prone or supine position, the nucleus of our strength training
for TA should be done standing upright, resisting gravity as a compressive
force.
Some of your more effective exercises for strengthening TA are the OH
Press, Upright row, BB Bent Over Row, Squat, Deadlift, Lunge, Cleans and
Snatches.
The key to getting the most out of these exercises with the additional
benefit of strengthening TA is to be aware of your posture in particular
the curvature of your spine and to keep your technique immaculate.
When Looking at dysfunctional people, especially people with disc bulges
who have been given the all clear by the physiotherapist to start participating
in a light resistance training program with additional TA strengthening,
the usual choices would be Pilate machines or sitting on Swiss Balls with
light resistance. Once again I ask the question “are these options
the only options open to us and are these options the better options open
to us”? The above mentioned resistance training exercises used by
functional people to strengthen TA aren’t going to be the preferred
option as the compressive force of gravity even with light resistance
could put pressure on the disc bulge and therefor aggravate the disc bulge.
A while ago I did a “Network” correspondence course by Everett
Aaberg who mentioned that you could strengthen TA by standing on one leg.
The rationale to this is if you are sitting on a Swiss Ball you are sitting
on an unstable environment there for TA comes into to play, like wise
if you are standing on one leg your body becomes unstable therefor TA
must come into play. I liked the option of standing on one leg as apposed
to sitting on a Swiss Ball as our evolutionary process designed TA to
resist gravity so we can stand upright. I’ve personally used the
method of standing on one leg with light resistance for disc bulge clients
with fantastic results. I find that isolation exercises such as a DB lateral
raise and the DB front raise with the arm locked straight at the elbow
joint, done with light weight and higher reps to help minimize the amount
of shearing force placed on the shoulder (eg.15-20 reps) to be very effective.
With a DB lateral raise or a DB front raise you have the use of long lever
to lift a resistance a considerable distance away from your bodies center
line of gravity. This in turn challenges your body’s ability to
remain balanced and not fall over, this in turn stresses TA to stabilize
your trunk area. This type of training has the additional benefit of incorporating
some ankle stability, knee stability and some hip stability.
To get the most out this type of workout you need to keep tension on your
mid section (ab bracing), keep perfect posture, stay rigid through the
trunk area and isolate movement to the shoulder joint only. You can also
incorporate other free weight exercises with use of a shorter lever (which
will be nearly as effective) such as a DB bicep curl etc. so long as you
adhere to the guidelines given to you by the physiotherapist. (Remember
the principle of “Individuality” not all clients are going
to feel comfortable standing on one leg, in which case, sit them on a
Swiss Ball or find another appropriate alternative).
|
| |
PART
4
What is Training
When looking back at earths
history, the firsts signs of life appeared around 1,500,000,000 years
ago. The first mammals appeared around 200,000,000 years ago, the first
primates appeared around 40,000,000 years ago and around 2,000,000 years
ago the first humans appeared (Patrick Doncaster. The timetable of human
evolution and cultural development). Over the past 1, 500,000,000 years,
millions of species have come and gone, the survival of a species largely
depends on its ability to adapt to changes in its environment. Nearly
all species have the ability to adapt to minor changes in their environment,
those that can’t die, while others that are better equipped to deal
with the change go onto produce offspring that are equally equipped or
even more equipped to adapt to the environmental
changes that have occurred (natural selection).
Humans have evolved to populate nearly every corner of the planet. They
have adapted to live in the coldest regions of North Alaska to some of
the hottest deserts in Central Australia to the highest altitudes of the
Himalayas.
Currently 17% of the worlds population live in the developed world, this
means that allot of us have had to adapt to the technological revolution.
This particular adaptive phase in the evolution of humans is responsible
for the higher rate of inactivity, obesity and poor health in many people.
Below are examples of two different working environments and the adaptation
processes involved.
EXAMPLE 1
If we look at a typical office worker that spends on average 8 hours a
day sitting at a computer, 5-6 days a week, their adaptation to their
environment is as follows.
1) Shortening of their hipflexors and hamstrings from sitting all day
(these muscles are important for maintaining correct pelvic alignment).
2) Deterioration of other postural muscles
3) Atrophy of the heart muscle.
4) Loss of elasticity in blood vessels.
5) Loss of lung function.
6) Often overweight or obese from inactivity.
EXAMPLE 2
If we look at a laborer (eg. a brickies laborer) who spends 8 hours a
day, 5-6 days a week moving bricks and morter around their adaptation
to their environment would be as follows.
1) Some increase in over all muscle mass.
2) Increase in overall strength, including core strength.
3) Increased lung function
4) Hypertrophy of the heart muscle, which will result in a greater stroke
volume.
5) Increased elasticity of blood vessels
6) Less likely to be overweight or obese due to the calories expended
over the working day.
Our evolutionary process and our ability to adapt allows us to adapt to
these types of conditions in a relatively short amount of time. Some of
the adaptations in the above two examples take effect in the matter of
weeks while others will take effect over months.
Training to improve sporting performance is no different, one could say
that example 1 is de-training while example 2 is training, even though
the thought of de-training or training was probably the last thing on
the minds of individuals when applying for these types of jobs.
The main difference between the individuals in the above two working environments
and individuals specifically training to improve sporting performance,
is that the individuals in example 1 and 2 put up with their working environment
in the pursuit of financial gains, where the individuals in pursuit of
improving athletic performance are in control of their environment and
are able to manipulate their environment to bring about the biological
changes needed for them to excel in their chosen sports.
|
| |
Conclusion
When it comes to training we
are often faced with decisions, free weights or machines? What is a more
effective or appropriate exercise? Isolation or compound? Pilates? Swiss
balls? Weight belts? etc .etc.
Watching documentaries on pay TV, surfing the internet, further educating
my self with courses along with reading quality books and articles on
Sport Science has shaped my way of thinking and given me a better understanding
of our existence on this planet. This article is about how I’ve
come to understand the environment around me and how the environment around
me effects the decisions that I make |
| |
References
Gravity Hurts by Karen Miller.
www.firstscience.com.
Bio Design by Everett Aaberg
(correspondence course)
Australian Fitness Network.
www.fitnessnetwork.com.au
The timetable of human evolution
and cultural development.
www.soton.ac.uk |
| |
| |
| Download
this article in PDF format |
132Kb |
| To view
the above article as a PDF you need to instal ADOBE ACROBAT READER. This
is a freely available plug-in/software available from ADOBE at www.adobe.com
or simply click the logo to go there... |
|
|
| |